Wednesday, January 27, 2016: 8:00 AM-9:30 AM
The Great Debate
Chair:
Jaya Mukhopadhyay, Ph.D., Montana State University
Technical Committee: 04.07 Energy Calculations
This seminar presents the different techniques that are available for calibrating simulation models. The seminar also presents the ongoing research that has been conducted to develop methods to test calibration techniques.
1.00 Calibration of Building Energy Simplified Simulation Models: Approaches and Applications
Simplified simulation models can be used for determination of effectiveness of energy-conservation measures in design stage as well as assessing performance optimization measures in retro-commissioning process. This presentation will deal with the general approaches that are followed to calibrate simplified simulations – auto and manual. The presentation will also show some examples on how the calibrated simulation can be used in practice.
2.00 Bayesian Calibration: Calibrating Energy Models with Uncertainty
Bayesian calibration is one of many methods that can be used for calibrating building energy models. In Bayesian calibration, modelers start from an assumption that parameters to be calibrated are uncertain through assignment of probability distribution functions. The Bayesian calibration algorithm adjusts the parameter probability distribution functions by comparison of model predictions to measured data. The posterior parameter distributions parameters are statistically more consistent with the measured data than the prior distributions with the probability distributions representing the confidence of the values of the input parameters given both the model of the buildings and the observed values from the building.
3.00 A Method of Test for Evaluating the Efficacy of Model Calibration Techniques
This paper summarizes a method for testing model calibration procedures. We call this a pure test method because it tests only the calibration procedure and not the correctness of the associated simulation program. This is accomplished by using the simulation program (used with a calibration method) to generate synthetic/surrogate building energy use data for a pre and post retrofit test case. Thus the “correct” inputs are precisely known and the calibration technique can be tested for closure on the correct pre-retrofit model input values and the post retrofit energy savings along with the usual “goodness of fit” criterion.
4.00 Autotune Calibration and Trinity Test Evaluation
Autotune project has developed and tested automated tuning methodologies that enable building energy models to reproduce measured data by systematically adjusting input parameters so they match the real building. Research addressing practical considerations related to data integrity, application of domain-agnostic, multi-parameter, optimization techniques and testing methods are discussed. A standard method of test for calibration tools is being developed and an online Trinity Test web service implements one of the methods recommended to allow determination of whether the inputs set by a calibration algorithm are the correct values for the given building.